Category members slammed side “left” because of their status to the groundbreaking, as well as the fresh “right”, since they are so hated Stalinist cult of your people
In the June 1952, the guy leftover the firm which have many supporters, however, after a short time, the guy returned once more. (24) Two postings later blogged regarding diary, that explains the distinctions from thoughts that are available in the classification. Castoriadis still support the indisputable fact that brand new Socialisme ou Barbarie need to end up being good spring up to possess a significant vanguard group; Lefort, while doing so, apply a clinical service workers’ manage from the main-stream convinced. Castoriadis substance of one’s disagreement is that the classification need contribute on the overthrow and destruction from capitalist society in addition to bourgeois condition. For this reason a governmental group needed to head and mengkoorinasikan opposition of your pros. The essential contradiction involving the movie director (management – trans) and you will subordinate work, and therefore dominates this new eastern and you can western, can not be terminated simply by one blast: the latest party must try and lead a unique dissolution. Yet , which dissolution are only able to happen following the trend. (25) The positioning Lefort in such a case isn’t problems you to definitely is very important to reach a major organization, but instead a point of workers’ stamina. The only path the proletariat can be build their strength is through the brand new different independent company. What you relies on this situation rather than toward people, which is merely an expression who has usually come another type of experience of workers and that is inadequate or even undesired in other activities. Thanks to this Socialisme ou Barbarie should not be so concentrated to your revolution as well as the seizure regarding county fuel, in place of a matter of experience of the working group inside the the entire process of organizing itself. (26) Next article subsequent elaborates Lefort updates and try to get acquainted with the fresh new “connection with the new proletariat” since a leading principle working-category existence. (27) With this particular strategy Lefort getting an essential precursor jobs afterwards taking a look at capitalism “out-of lower than” that do Raniero Panzieri, Edward matchbox Thompson, Erhard Lucas although some.
The effectiveness of the employees exactly who make wave you’ll, however, a wave wouldn’t be certain that workers’ power
Hot inner discussion within the category immediately with a discussion with others outside of the category about the same issues. Significant – plus clear, because from dissent – that’s nearly immediately a division regarding labor created anywhere between Lefort and you can Castoriadis. The latter got a defensive posture up against rivals of one’s idea of one’s people, given that very first discover assault to people exactly who acknowledge the newest notion of this new revolutionary class.
Within the November 1953 Anton Pannekoek, a favorite ageing Communist Council of Netherlands, sent a letter to Socialisme ainsi que Barbarie that has been and additionally wrote from the diary. (28) In his letter Pannekoek typed which he sympathized on group in manners, however, the guy also offers several simple more viewpoint: the latest research of 1917 Russian revolution, and matter of the latest vanguard class. In lieu of Socialisme ainsi que Barbarie, the guy don’t look at the Oct trend once the a great proletarian uprising, and therefore later degenerated to your a bureaucratic county capitalism, however, the guy said from the beginning it was a great bourgeois enjoy, which will not become you’ll be able to to make socialism. Toward issue of the pioneer teams, it’s completely compared Pannekoek. The guy believed that revolutionaries ought not to build a party but are merely stepping into propaganda and you can theoretic arguments. Work is requiring workers’ electricity and never “lead” this new liberation endeavor.
Into the respond, Castoriadis focused on organizational factors master. One particular fundamental postulate is strictly since the revolutionaries don’t generate an event, therefore paving just how towards development off bureaucratic dictatorship, as the happened on Soviet Relationship.
댓글을 남겨주세요