Sum)
We chose to reanalyse a recent empirical report with the cph because of the DeKeyser mais aussi al. (henceforth DK et al.). Which paper lends in itself really so you can an excellent reanalysis because exhibits one or two highly noble functions: the brand new experts explain its hypotheses lucidly and offer intricate mathematical and you will graphical research descriptions. Additionally, the paper’s direct author is extremely clear on what comprises a good expected status for recognizing brand new cph : a low-linearity on the age of start of acquisition ( aoa )–ultimate attainment ( ua ) setting, having ua decreasing quicker strongly since the a function of aoa during the elderly, post- cp arrivals than the more youthful arrivals , . Lastly, it states are finding mix-linguistic evidence out of two synchronous degree support the new cph and ought to hence end up being an unsuspected supply to cph supporters.
DK mais aussi al. establish investigation out of comparable review on relationship anywhere between aoa and you can ua in morphosyntactic decisions in two categories of adult Russian-talking immigrants who had already been understanding English ( ) otherwise Hebrew ( ) once the an L2 during the various other many years in United states and you can Israel, respectively. This new grammaticality reasoning task ( gjt ) is adjusted regarding Johnson and you can Newport’s research and you can is actually incontri birazziali gratis exhibited auditorily. For each of your own 204 activities, the newest new member must imply whether it is an excellent permissible utterance from the respective L2 or perhaps not. One point are awarded for every proper address. Participants were divided into three aoa organizations: individuals who emigrated up until the age 18 (young), those people between the period of 18 and you may 40 (middle) and people who showed up immediately following many years 40 (old). Concurrently, all people grabbed a spoken abilities try. For further details, We relate to the original book.
Theory step one: For both the L2 English in addition to L2 Hebrew category, the newest mountain of the age arrival–greatest attainment form will not be linear on lifetime, however, usually as an alternative let you know a marked flattening between puberty and you can adulthood.
Hypothesis 2: The partnership ranging from abilities and you can best attainment will differ significantly having the students and you can earlier arrivals, that have advantages only for the second. (DK mais aussi al., p. 417)
One another hypotheses was supposedly verified, which in the newest authors’ view will bring facts in favour of cph . The situation using this type of end, not, is the fact it is according to an evaluation away from relationship coefficients. As i provides argued a lot more than, relationship coefficients are not to be mistaken for regression coefficients and you will can’t be used to really address research hypotheses in regards to the slopes, such as Hypothesis step 1. ‘s aoa and you may gjt research so you’re able to target Hypothesis step 1. Likewise, I could set bare an issue with how Hypothesis 2 is actually handled. The brand new removed analysis as well as the pc code used in the newest reanalysis are offered once the second information, allowing people curious so you’re able to scrutinise and easily reproduce my whole investigation and you can do their own data (come across ‘supporting information’).
Analysis extraction
DK ainsi que al. given higher-solution scatterplots, online on journal’s site, in order to illustrate the relationship anywhere between aoa and you may gjt abilities. Using the open origin program g3data, i extracted the information and knowledge underlying such scatterplots. g3data try downloadable from while offering a screen in which profiles basic identify the new – and -axes out-of a great scatterplot following area and then click into studies affairs inside it to pull the brand new – and you may -coordinates of the picked affairs. For the Israel studies, i decided to round off the aoa studies into nearby integer, because the are the scenario regarding the United states research, unlike towards the earliest erica and Israel studies are given as the Datasets S1 and S2, respectively.
댓글을 남겨주세요