Brand new dominating unspoken philosophical basis off medical care regarding Joined Claims is actually a variety of Cartesian reductionism one to viewpoints one’s body while the a servers and you may physicians because the technicians whoever work is to correct that host. The goal of which paper would be to suggest to have an option philosophy out-of medication according to the notion of recuperation dating ranging from clinicians and you will people. This is accomplished first of the examining the ethical and you can philosophical work out-of Pellegrino and Thomasma and then by the connecting Martin Buber’s philosophical work on the type of dating so you can a keen empirically derived model of scientific recuperation relationships. Brand new Healing Dating Model is made because of the authors because of qualitative investigation of interview from medical professionals and you will clients. Clinician-diligent recovery matchmaking are a new kind of exactly what Buber phone calls I-Thou relationship, described as dialog and you can mutuality, however, a mutuality limited by the fresh new inherent asymmetry of one’s clinician-patient matchmaking. The newest Healing Matchmaking Model relates to three techniques essential instance dating to grow and get suffered: Respecting, Admiring Power and you can Abiding. We talk about in detail just how these processes, and also other parts of the latest model resonate that have Buber’s axioms off We-Thou and i also-They relationship. The latest resulting joint abstract model illuminates the new wholeness root the fresh new twin positions out of doctors due to the fact healers and you will team out-of technical biomedicine. Based on the research, we argue that healthcare are focused on healing, with We-Thou matchmaking from the the center.
History
Inside a recent article regarding the his prognosis of prostate disease, New york Moments publisher Dana Jennings typed, “Physicians will standard to help you simple skilled reliability, forgetting to speak to the fresh terrified skin-and-bloodstream guy influence the illness.” Particularly complaint away from drug in the us isn’t the newest, however it is becoming more and more clear that medical philosophical condition one “takes into account human beings simply selections regarding body organ solutions and dumps out of condition entities” is not fulfilling the requirements of patients otherwise fitness-care experts.
One to unspoken philosophical status fundamental progressive healthcare are a kind of Cartesianism(p 99), the theory one to bodies was machines which doctors is actually technicians whoever employment it’s to repair men and women computers. While this scientific Cartesian reductionism has received unquestionable victory during the dancing biomedical knowledge, and also lead to important treatments to ease peoples suffering, it’s at the same time the underlying of several away from the problems in our health care program.
Pellegrino and Thomasma propose a choice thinking away from medication. They explain drug as the “a relation out-of shared agree to effect custom really-are by the working in, with, and you will through the human body”(p 80). Dating-App für Hundefreunde Ergo, inside their system the midst of medicine try dating, together with reason for you to relationships is actually data recovery(p 177). This is simply not so you can refuse the necessity of tech proficiency gained throughout the reductionist medical enterprise. Just like the Pellegrino and you may Thomasma explain, “this new work out-of medical community was inauthentic and you will a rest unless of course they meets the brand new expectation off tech skills(p 213).” Tech ability, however, try a necessary but not enough updates having recuperation. “Competence need to by itself become molded towards the end of the scientific work – the right and you will a good recuperation step to have a particular diligent(p 213).”
Data recovery dating as well as the existential beliefs of Martin Buber
Pellegrino and you can Thomasma determine a data recovery action because the “a right and you will wise course of action for this particular patient,” and keep maintaining one to recovery is actually on the other hand the prospective (telos) of systematic medication and you can inherent regarding characteristics of one’s systematic run into alone. Pellegrino lines particular top-notch virtues which can be wanted to go recuperation steps, but spends almost no time to the specifics of how healing relationships is developed. The intention of this paper is to speak about in detail this new character of the medical healing matchmaking utilizing the Healing Dating Design, an abstract design brand new experts setup owing to qualitative data out of interview regarding physicians and you may clients, in order to hook up which design in order to Martin Buber’s philosophical manage the kind away from matchmaking. We make the circumstances that the lengthened brand of recuperation dating, relating to Pellegrino and Thomasma’s beliefs, you’ll act as a good theoretic basis up against and that to measure latest efforts in order to change the new U.S. medical system.
댓글을 남겨주세요